Abstract
We make sense of human behavior using reasons, which produce understanding via a subjective empathy-based first-person perspective and causes, which leads to explanations utilizing objective facts about the world assessed scientifically. We evaluate the common sense hypothesis that for episodes of major depression (MD), reasons act as causes. That is, individuals who have highly understandable depressive episodes will have, on average, fewer objective scientifically validated causes than those who have un-understandable episodes. The understandability of a MD as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, 4th Edition (DSM IV) experienced in the past year in 630 personally interviewed twins from a population-based registry was rated, with high reliability, from rich contextual information. We predicted, from these understandability ratings, via linear and logistic regression, 12 validated risk factors for MD reflecting genetic and long-term environmental liability. No significant association was observed between 11 of these indices and the understandability of the depressive episode. The only significant finding—higher cotwin risk for MD associated with greater understandability—was opposite that predicted by the reasons-as-causes hypothesis. Our results do not support the hypothesis that reasons for MD act as causes. These findings, unlikely to result from low power, may be explicable from an empirical and/or philosophical perspective. Our results are, however, consistent with ‘the trap of meaning’ hypothesis, which suggests that understanding does not equal explanation and that while reasons may be critical to help us empathize with our patients, they are unreliable indices of objective risk factors for illness.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 12 print issues and online access
$259.00 per year
only $21.58 per issue
Buy this article
- Purchase on Springer Link
- Instant access to full article PDF
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Jaspers K . General Psychopathology. University of Chicago Press: Chicago, 1963.
Sullivan PF, Neale MC, Kendler KS . Genetic epidemiology of major depression: review and meta-analysis. Am J Psychiatry 2000; 157: 1552–1562.
Lyketsos CG, Chisolm MS . The trap of meaning: a public health tragedy. JAMA 2009; 302: 432–433.
Kendler KS, Prescott CA . Genes, Environment, and Psychopathology: Understanding the Causes of Psychiatric and Substance Use Disorders. Guilford Press: New York, 2006.
Brown GW, Harris TO . Life Events and Illness. Guilford Press: New York, 1989.
Fleiss J . The equivalence of weighted kappa and the intraclass correlation coefficient as measures of reliability. Educ Psychol Meas 1973; 33: 613–619.
Endicott J, Andreasen N, Spitzer RL . Family History-Research Diagnostic Criteria. New York State Psychiatric Institute, Biometrics Research Department: New York, 1975.
Eysenck SBG, Eysenck HJ, Barrett P . A revised version of the psychoticism scale. Pers Individ Dif 1985; 6: 21–29.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Revised. 3rd edn. American Psychiatric Association: Washington, DC, 1987.
American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. 3rd edn. American Psychiatric Association: Washington, DC, 1980.
Kendler KS, Gardner CO, Prescott CA . Panic syndromes in a population-based sample of male and female twins. Psychol Med 2001; 31: 989–1000.
Parker G, Tupling H, Brown L . A parental bonding instrument. Br J Med Psychol 1979; 52: 1–10.
Kendler KS, Bulik CM, Silberg J, Hettema JM, Myers J, Prescott CA . Childhood sexual abuse and adult psychiatric and substance use disorders in women: an epidemiological and cotwin control analysis. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2000; 57: 953–959.
SAS Institute. SAS ONLINE DOC Version 9.2, 2002–2008. SAS Institute: Cary, NC, 2008. Ref type: Data File.
Kendler KS, Thornton LM, Gardner CO . Stressful life events and previous episodes in the etiology of major depression in women: an evaluation of the ‘kindling’ hypothesis. Am J Psychiatry 2000; 157: 1243–1251.
Post RM . Transduction of psychosocial stress into the neurobiology of recurrent affective disorder. Am J Psychiatry 1992; 149: 999–1010.
Ezquiaga E, Ayuso Gutierrez JL, Garcia LA . Psychosocial factors and episode number in depression. J Affect Disord 1987; 12: 135–138.
Brown GW, Harris TO, Hepworth C . Life events and endogenous depression. A puzzle reexamined. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1994; 51: 525–534.
Kendler KS, Neale MC, Kessler RC, Heath AC, Eaves LJ . A longitudinal twin study of personality and major depression in women. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1993; 50: 853–862.
Kendler KS, Gatz M, Gardner C, Pedersen NL . Personality and major depression: a Swedish longitudinal, population-based twin study. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2006; 63: 1113–1120.
Angst J, Clayton P . Premorbid personality of depressive, bipolar, and schizophrenic patients with special reference to suicidal issues. Compr Psychiatry 1986; 27: 511–532.
Nystrom S, Lindegard B . Predisposition for mental syndromes: a study comparing predisposition for depression, neurasthenia and anxiety state. Acta Psychiatr Scand 1975; 51: 69–76.
Hirschfeld RMA, Klerman GL, Lavori PW, Keller MB, Griffith P, Coryell W . Premorbid personality assessments of first onset of major depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1989; 46: 345–350.
Boyce P, Parker G, Barnett B, Cooney M, Smith F . Personality as a vulnerability factor to depression. Br J Psychiatry 1991; 159: 106–114.
Krueger RF . The structure of common mental disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1999; 56: 921–926.
Krueger RF, Caspi A, Moffitt TE, Silva PA . The structure and stability of common mental disorders (DSM-III-R): a longitudinal-epidemiological study. J Abnorm Psychol 1998; 107: 216–227.
Kendler KS, Prescott CA, Myers J, Neale MC . The structure of genetic and environmental risk factors for common psychiatric and substance use disorders in men and women. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2003; 60: 929–937.
Kendler KS, Gatz M, Gardner CO, Pedersen NL . Clinical indices of familial depression in the Swedish Twin Registry. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2007; 115: 214–220.
Kendler KS, Myers J, Prescott CA . Parenting and adult mood, anxiety and substance use disorders in female twins: an epidemiological, multi-informant, retrospective study. Psychol Med 2000; 30: 281–294.
Kendler KS, Sheth K, Gardner CO, Prescott CA . Childhood parental loss and risk for first-onset of major depression and alcohol dependence: the time-decay of risk and sex differences. Psychol Med 2002; 32: 1187–1194.
Parker G . The parental bonding instrument. A decade of research. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol 1990; 25: 281–282.
Fergusson DM, Mullen PE . Childhood Sexual Abuse: An Evidence Based Perspective. Sage Publications: Thousand Oaks, CA, 1999.
Joffe RT, Levitt AJ, Bagby RM, Regan JJ . Clinical-features of situational and nonsituational major depression. Psychopathology 1993; 26: 138–144.
Hirschfeld RM . Situational depression: validity of the concept. Br J Psychiatry 1981; 139: 297–305.
McGuffin P, Katz R, Bebbington P . The camberwell collaborative depression study. III. Depression and adversity in the relatives of depressed probands. Br J Psychiatry 1988; 152: 775–782.
Winokur G, Pitts Jr FN . Affective disorder. I. Is reactive depression an entity? J Nerv Ment Dis 1964; 138: 541–547.
Kendler KS, Myers J, Halberstadt LJ . Should the diagnosis of major depression be made independent of or dependent upon the psychosocial context? Psychol Med 2010; 40: 771–780.
Coryell W, Winokur G, Maser JD, Akiskal HS, Keller MB, Endicott J . Recurrently situational (reactive) depression: a study of course, phenomenology and familial psychopathology. J Affect Disord 1994; 31: 203–210.
Zimmerman M, Pfohl B, Stangl D, Coryell W . The validity of DSM-III axis IV (severity of psychosocial stressors). Am J Psychiatry 1985; 142: 1437–1441.
Kendler KS, Myers J, Prescott CA . The etiology of phobias: an evaluation of the stress-diathesis model. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2002; 59: 242–248.
Kendler KS, Baker JH . Genetic influences on measures of the environment: a systematic review. Psychol Med 2007; 37: 615–626.
Kendler KS, Karkowski-Shuman L . Stressful life events and genetic liability to major depression: genetic control of exposure to the environment? Psychol Med 1997; 27: 539–547.
Kendler KS, Karkowski LM, Prescott CA . Causal relationship between stressful life events and the onset of major depression. Am J Psychiatry 1999; 156: 837–841.
Kendler KS, Gardner CO . Dependent stressful life events and prior depressive episodes in the prediction of major depression: the problem of causal inference in psychiatric epidemiology. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2010; 67: 1120–1127.
Wikipedia Contributors. Wilhelm Dilthey (23 June 2010). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, Retrieved 17:44, 12 July 2010, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wilhelm_Dilthey&oldid=369814642. Page version ID: 369814642.
Cohen J . Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. Academic Press: Orlando, FL, 1977.
Acknowledgements
Supported in part by NIH grants MH-40828 and MH/AA/DA-49492. Dr James L Levenson provided helpful comments on earlier versions of this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kendler, K., Myers, J. & Halberstadt, L. Do reasons for major depression act as causes?. Mol Psychiatry 16, 626–633 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1038/mp.2011.22
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/mp.2011.22
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Evidence that stress per se has a role in the precipitation and natural history of depressive illness
Molecular Psychiatry (2013)
-
The road not taken: life experiences in monozygotic twin pairs discordant for major depression
Molecular Psychiatry (2013)
-
Identifying false, but apparently plausible, explanations for the onset of psychiatric disorder
Molecular Psychiatry (2012)