Table 2 Anthropometric measurements (A), blood biochemistries (B) and dietary intakes (C) at baseline and week-4 of study
(A) | Baseline | Week-4 | Repeated measures ANOVA (Greenhouse–Geisser) a | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean±s.d. | Mean± s.d. | Time, P | Group, P | Timeb Group, P | ||
Body weight, kg | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 77.2±16.8 | 77.2±17.2 | |||
BF | n=28 | 80.5±15.0 | 80.7±14.8 | |||
MS | n=28 | 83.2±21.1 | 83.2±21.3 | 0.023b | 0.510 | 0.357 |
LN | n=26 | 84.8±13.7 | 85.1±13.4 | |||
AS | n=28 | 81.8±14.6 | 81.9±15.8 | |||
BMI, kg/m 2 | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 27.0±4.4 | 26.9±4.4 | |||
BF | n=28 | 28.2±4.8 | 28.3±4.7 | |||
MS | n=28 | 28.7±5.0 | 28.7±5.1 | 0.011b | 0.547 | 0.627 |
LN | n=26 | 29.0±3.9 | 29.1±3.9 | |||
AS | n=28 | 28.2±5.2 | 28.3±5.3 | |||
Waist, cm | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 81.9±12.4 | 82.3±12.4 | |||
BF | n=28 | 85.3±12.2 | 85.0±12.4 | |||
MS | n=28 | 85.6±11.4 | 85.8±11.6 | <0.001b | 0.585 | 0.010b |
LN | n=26 | 87.0±9.9 | 87.2±9.7 | |||
AS | n=28 | 86.2±11.2 | 86.0±11.0 | |||
Body fat mass, kg | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 26.3±10.5 | 26.2±10.4 | |||
BF | n=28 | 28.1±11.2 | 28.0±11.2 | |||
MS | n=28 | 28.1±10.2 | 28.1±10.9 | 0.151 | 0.988 | 0.922 |
LN | n=26 | 28.5±9.2 | 28.2±9.3 | |||
AS | n=28 | 27.3±10.7 | 27.0±11.2 | |||
Systolic blood pressure, mmHg | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 121.2±11.5 | 117.8±12.5 | |||
BF | n=28 | 123.9±12.5 | 121.5±14.9 | |||
MS | n=28 | 122.7±11.9 | 122.6±11.0 | 0.023b | 0.047b | 0.481 |
LN | n=26 | 128.4±14.8 | 128.4±10.9 | |||
AS | n=28 | 127.7±11.6 | 124.1±10.2 | |||
Diastolic blood pressure, mmHg | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 74.6±8.0 | 72.2±9.3 | |||
BF | n=28 | 77.1±10.3 | 76.3±11.0 | |||
MS | n=28 | 76.1±9.1 | 74.3±8.5 | 0.020b | 0.438 | 0.713 |
LN | n=26 | 78.7±11.9 | 76.6±11.7 | |||
AS | n=28 | 76.8±7.9 | 76.8±6.7 |
(B) | Baseline | Week-4 | Repeated measures ANOVA (Greenhouse–Geisser) a | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean± s.d. | Mean± s.d. | Time, P | Group, P | Timeb Group, P | ||
Fasting serum glucose, mg/dl | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 92.3±9.7 | 92.2±10.0 | |||
BF | n=28 | 89.0±7.8 | 91.3±0.9 | |||
MS | n=28 | 93.8±18.4 | 90.1±9.1 | 0.003b | 0.877 | 0.733 (adj. BMI 0.084) |
LN | n=26 | 92.6±9.4 | 92.5±9.0 | |||
AS | n=28 | 91.4±8.9 | 91.9±11.5 | |||
Fasting serum triacylglycerol, mg/dl | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 93.3±44.4 | 98.3±50.2 | |||
BF | n=28 | 89.7±50.3 | 103.3±58.7 | |||
MS | n=28 | 92.6±51.6 | 90.4±41.2 | 0.001b | 0.849 | 0.260 (adj. BMI 0.855) |
LN | n=26 | 99.5±68.5 | 92.7±52.6 | |||
AS | n=28 | 112.2±43.7 | 95.6±37.0 | |||
Fasting serum total cholesterol, mg/dl | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 151.9±25.3 | 147.2±24.0 | |||
BF | n=28 | 152.3±23.2 | 153.4±26.9 | |||
MS | n=28 | 151.1±34.7 | 153.0±36.2 | <0.001b | 0.864 | 0.530 (adj. BMI 0.822) |
LN | n=26 | 154.1±32.4 | 149.0±26.4 | |||
AS | n=28 | 157.5±31.4 | 151.8±33.0 | |||
Fasting serum LDL cholesterol, mg/dl | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 89.1±22.6 | 83.9±21.7 | |||
BF | n=28 | 95.7±26.5 | 92.6±23.6 | |||
MS | n=28 | 93.5±29.3 | 95.9±29.7 | <0.001b | 0.726 | 0.636 (adj. BMI 0.981) |
LN | n=26 | 93.0±26.0 | 89.1±24.9 | |||
AS | n=28 | 97.0±28.5 | 92.0±28.3 | |||
Fasting serum HDL cholesterol, mg/dl | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 52.7±11.6 | 53.0±12.3 | |||
BF | n=28 | 48.3±14.8 | 49.6±18.3 | |||
MS | n=28 | 47.7±9.4 | 47.3±9.2 | <0.001b | 0.502 | 0.178 (adj. BMI 0.376) |
LN | n=26 | 51.0±15.7 | 52.0±14.7 | |||
AS | n=28 | 47.9±10.7 | 46.9±10.4 | |||
Fasting serum insulin, μU/ml | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 10.5±5.0 | 9.4±5.7 | |||
BF | n=28 | 9.0±5.7 | 11.1±11.3 | |||
MS | n=28 | 13.4±12.9 | 10.7±6.4 | 0.024b | 0.176 | 0.309 (adj. BMI 0.962) |
LN | n=26 | 13.2±5.7 | 13.5±8.1 | |||
AS | n=28 | 11.2±6.5 | 13.3±8.7 | |||
Fasting plasma α-tocopherol, mg/dl | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 6.39±1.62 | 6.26±1.45 | |||
BF | n=28 | 6.65±1.76 | 7.05±1.82 | |||
MS | n=28 | 5.90±1.33 | 6.15±1.36 | 0.181 | 0.541 | 0.333 |
LN | n=26 | 6.66±2.99 | 6.59±2.74 | |||
AS | n=28 | 6.43±2.02 | 6.59±1.55 |
(C) | Baseline | Week-4 | Repeated measures ANOVA (Greenhouse-Geisser) a | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean±s.d. | Mean±s.d. | Time, P | Group, P | Timeb Group, P | ||
Energy intake, kcal/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 1890±539 | 1719±661 | |||
BF | n=28 | 2026±754 | 1969±667 | |||
MS | n=28 | 2223±795 | 2216±749 | 0.573 | 0.035b | 0.806 |
LN | n=26 | 2036±718 | 2082±719 | |||
AS | n=28 | 1948±748 | 1878±685 | |||
Fat intake, g/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 72.8±27.3 | 69.0±42.4 | |||
BF | n=28 | 82.8±45.4 | 90.0±42.0 | |||
MS | n=28 | 84.1±36.1 | 96.4±34.9 | 0.057 | 0.033b | 0.583 |
LN | n=26 | 82.3±38.9 | 88.2±31.5 | |||
AS | n=28 | 73.3±37.1 | 85.0±30.2 | |||
Carbohydrate intake, g/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 228.5±90.6 | 216.0±84.9 | |||
BF | n=28 | 251.9±90.6 | 220.6±69.5 | |||
MS | n=28 | 285.0±114.1 | 259.0±108.8 | 0.062 | 0.057 | 0.710 |
LN | n=26 | 244.7±88.2 | 242.3±113.9 | |||
AS | n=28 | 239.8±105.6 | 204.4±101.6 | |||
Protein intake, g/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 76.6±34.9 | 63.9±26.4 | |||
BF | n=28 | 76.9±33.7 | 76.1±30.6 | |||
MS | n=28 | 79.3±33.6 | 88.9±42.7 | 0.755 | 0.123 | 0.373 |
LN | n=26 | 84.8±31.4 | 84.1±26.7 | |||
AS | n=28 | 75.7±42.8 | 73.9±32.6 | |||
Alcohol intake, g/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 6.3±23.9 | 1.4±5.3 | |||
BF | n=28 | 1.2±4.1 | 1.9±10.3 | |||
MS | n=28 | 6.7±22.6 | 1.3±5.6 | 0.240 | 0.762 | 0.334 |
LN | n=26 | 0.6±2.7 | 2.4±7.1 | |||
AS | n=28 | 1.8±4.9 | 1.0±5.2 | |||
Dietary cholesterol (mg/day) | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 259±208 | 227±299 | |||
BF | n=28 | 266±213 | 228±230 | |||
MS | n=28 | 259±209 | 286±250 | 0.437 | 0.705 | 0.890 |
LN | n=26 | 283±217 | 256±160 | |||
AS | n=28 | 276±198 | 231±174 | |||
Dietary saturated fat, g/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 26.4±14.8 | 23.0±16.3 | |||
BF | n=28 | 31.1±21.3 | 25.7±15.3 | |||
MS | n=28 | 29.5±15.2 | 27.3±14.5 | 0.066 | 0.561 | 0.990 |
LN | n=26 | 27.2±12.7 | 23.5±10.1 | |||
AS | n=28 | 27.2±18.2 | 24.7±12.3 | |||
Dietary monounsaturated fat, g/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 24.9±9.9 | 22.5±14.5 | |||
BF | n=28 | 28.4±16.0 | 36.3±13.2 | |||
MS | n=28 | 28.7±14.0 | 39.0±11.6 | <0.001b | <0.001b | 0.036b |
LN | n=26 | 29.0±15.6 | 37.3±12.1 | |||
AS | n=28 | 27.3±14.5 | 35.8±12.7 | |||
Dietary polyunsaturated fat, g/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 15.3±7.2 | 18.0±12.5 | |||
BF | n=28 | 16.2±8.5 | 21.3±13.6 | |||
MS | n=28 | 19.1±11.3 | 22.8±11.2 | 0.008b | 0.064 | 0.323 |
LN | n=26 | 19.9±13.0 | 20.7±10.9 | |||
AS | n=28 | 17.6±9.1 | 17.8±7.9 | |||
Dietary fiber, g/d | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 14.7±8.3 | 18.4±11.5 | |||
BF | n=28 | 21.2±12.6 | 19.7±8.3 | |||
MS | n=28 | 21.2±11.9 | 23.4±12.2 | 0.128 | 0.010b | 0.706 |
LN | n=26 | 17.0±6.0 | 19.0±9.0 | |||
AS | n=28 | 16.7±7.9 | 15.9±6.2 | |||
Dietary α-tocopherol, mg/day | ||||||
CL | n=27 | 13.9±24.1 | 9.1±5.5 | <0.001b | <0.001b | <0.001b |
BF | n=28 | 10.2±6.7 | 17.6±3.4 | |||
MS | n=28 | 12.3±8.1 | 24.4±13.2 | |||
LN | n=26 | 11.2±8.5 | 18.8±6.0 | |||
AS | n=28 | 11.4±8.5 | 17.6±6.6 |