Abstract
Due to reconnection or recombination of neighboring strands superfluid vortex knots and DNA plasmid torus knots and links are found to undergo an almost identical cascade process, that tend to reduce topological complexity by stepwise unlinking. Here, by using the HOMFLYPT polynomial recently introduced for fluid knots, we prove that under the assumption that topological complexity decreases by stepwise unlinking this cascade process follows a path detected by a unique, monotonically decreasing sequence of numerical values. This result holds true for any sequence of standardly embedded torus knots T(2, 2n + 1) and torus links T(2, 2n). By this result we demonstrate that the computation of this adapted HOMFLYPT polynomial provides a powerful tool to measure topological complexity of various physical systems.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Vortex filaments in classical and quantum fluids1,2, magnetic flux tubes3, phase defects4, polymers and DNA macromolecules5,6 may interact and recombine through reconnection of neighboring strands. Details of the process depend on specific local mechanisms that may differ from case to case, but certain qualitative features — such as the preservation of the original strand orientation after recombination — are generic and common to all systems. In the majority of cases orientation-preserving reconnections occur when neighboring strands tend to align (at the time of closest approach) in an anti-parallel fashion7,8,9,10, before transversal merging and final separation. The prototype process is schematically shown in Fig. 1a, where the reconnection of two anti-parallel strands of a single structure (stage (i), in orange) produces a new structure given by a pair of loops (stage (ii), in orange and blue). In general, when two disjoint, closed tubes (representing vortex rings or DNA macromolecules) reconnect, the result is a single closed tube, and when a single closed tube reconnects with itself, the result is two closed tubes. Of course this process is not unique and depends crucially on the particular initial condition, as shown in Fig. 1b, where a trefoil vortex knot undergoing two simultaneous reconnection events produces two unlinked, unknotted vortex loops. The study of these processes is clearly of great importance, because the change of topology is often accompanied by a change in energy, entropy and function.
According to recent observations based on direct numerical simulations of decaying Bose-Einstein condensates11,12 and recombinant DNA plasmids13, both systems initially given by torus knots and links are found to undergo an almost identical cascade process through an alternate sequence of T(2, 2n + 1) torus knots and T(2, 2n) torus links as n (integer) decreases to 0. After every reconnection the knot/link seems to gradually untie by removing a single crossing at a time, by reducing consistently topological complexity (measured by the minimum number of crossings). Remarkably, this sequence of topological transitions seem to follow an identical topological decay pattern (shown in Fig. 2), irrespective of the physical context considered. This, we believe, is probably due to the particular choice of initial conditions given by the ideal shape configuration. Torus knots and links in ideal shape are maximally symmetric objects with optimal geometric regularity, crucial in the follow-up of the reconnection process. The counter-example of Fig. 1b (see also the envisaged process discussed in the section Concluding remarks) clearly shows how a very different initial condition far from ideal may produce a very different scenario.
In our recent derivation of Jones and HOMFLYPT polynomials for fluid knots14,15 we showed that these adapted polynomials can be used not only to detect topological differences between knots and links (as standard knot polynomials typically do), but also to measure topological differences between physical states. Here, by using our adapted HOMFLYPT polynomial we show that the particular cascade above can be detected by a unique, monotonically decreasing sequence of numerical values.
Methods
In general, polynomial computations for knots and links are based on the recursive application of two skein relations, by the use of diagrams16 obtained from the indented projection of a given knot with minimal crossings (see top diagram of Fig. 3). For tubular filaments these diagrams simply represent the tube centerline, with over-crossings and under-crossings to denote respectively over-passes and under-passes of tube strands. The first skein relation simply states that the polynomial value of the unknot (the trivial knot) is equal to 1. The second skein relation prescribes how a “state” associated with a particular crossing type, represented for example by the over-crossing , is related to its opposite, the under-crossing , and the relative “smoothing” given by two parallel strands (the non-crossing ). Standard knot polynomials are powerful topological invariants readily available from dedicated web-sites (such as KnotAtlas17). By identifying a physical knot with a space curve K of physical strength Φ (circulation, in the case of a vortex), we can extend standard knot polynomials by new polynomials that characterize physical knots in terms of knot type and strength15,18.
For physical knots the skein relations of the HOMFLYPT polynomial PK(a, z) (a two-variable polynomial in a and z) are given by15
with z = k − k−1 and
where ω = λωWr and τ = λτTw denote respectively reference values of writhe Wr and twist Tw of K19,20, weighted by the relative uncertainty (probability) factors {λω, λτ} ∈ (0, 1).
Since a and z admits respectively interpretation in terms of twist and writhe (independently), eq. (2) prescribes a relationship between twist contribution (from the left-hand-side) in terms of writhe. Hence eq. (2) provides a framing prescription for physical knots: thus, reduction of HOMFLYPT polynomial to Jones, that is a one-variable polynomial, implies that
Results
Let us make the following assumptions:
-
1
all torus knots T(2, 2n + 1) and links T(2, 2n) (with n = 0, 1, 2, …) considered here are standardly embedded on a mathematical torus in closed braid form;
-
2
all torus knots T(2, 2n + 1) and links T(2, 2n) form an ordered set {T(2, n)} () of elements listed according to their decreasing value of topological complexity given by the minimum number of crossings cmin = n;
-
3
any topological transition between two contiguous elements of {T(2, n)} is determined by a single, anti-parallel reconnection event21.
We can then prove the following, general result.
Theorem. Let us consider the family {T(2, n)} of torus knots and links. The HOMFLYPT polynomial of T(2, n) is given by
where PT(2,3) = 2a−2 + a−2z2 − a−4 and PT(2,2) = a−1z + (a−1 − a−3)z−1.
Proof. Let us consider the diagram of T(2, n + 2), and in particular a portion of it represented by the top diagram of Fig. 3 and apply the second skein relation to relate crossing sites. From (2) we have
that is
This is a recurrence relation between polynomials, so it can be written as
where α and β are two undetermined coefficients. By comparing (8) and (7) we have α + β = a−1z and αβ = −a−2, that combined together give a quadratic equation, with solutions
On the other hand, by applying (8) recursively we have
By rewriting (10) and computing recursively each contribution, we have
Now, by substituting consecutively each term we have
that is
By direct substitution we can see that both solutions (9) reduce (11) to the same, identical recurrence equation given by (5). This completes the proof. ◼
We can now apply the specifications (3). For simplicity, and without loss of generality, let’s set Φ = 1. By using (3) we can re-write (5) as
where
The family of torus knots and links considered earlier11,12,13 correspond to positive T(2, n) (i.e. of type shown in Fig. 2, with all over-crossings); for this knot family, denoted by {T(2, n)}+ reference values for Wr and Tw must be taken between 0 and 122. For the family {T(2, n)}− of mirror knots with all under-crossings, i.e. for negative T(2, n), the HOMFLYPT polynomial can be readily obtained by using the following lemma.
Lemma. Given the knot K, the HOMFLYPT polynomial of the mirror knot is given by replacing
into the HOMFLYPT polynomial of the knot K.
A straightforward proof of this Lemma is obtained by using the second skein relation (2).
For negative T(2, n) reference values for Wr and Tw must be taken between −1 and 022. Note that by using (13) and by replacing τ → −τ and ω → −ω, equation (12) remains unchanged. Hence, for any choice of Wr and Tw (consistently with positive or negative T(2, n)) and for any choice of the uncertainty values {λω, λτ} ∈ (0, 1) we obtain, for decreasing n, a monotonically decreasing sequence of HOMFLYPT values. We can thus prove the following corollary in full generality.
Corollary. Let us consider the family of torus knots and links {T(2, n)}±. HOMFLYPT computation of PT(2,n) generates, for decreasing n (), a monotonically decreasing sequence of numerical values given by (12).
Initial values are given by the HOMFLYPT computation of the 2-component unlink unknot T(2, 0), unknot T(2, 1), Hopf link T(2, 2) and trefoil knot T(2, 3)15. For the sake of example we can take λω = λτ = 1/2 (equivalent to an equi-distribution of uncertainty of writhe and twist values) and |Wr| = |Tw| = 1/2 to obtain the numerical values of the sequence shown in Fig. 4. Other values of λω and λτ would equally give a monotonically decreasing sequence.
The sequence is clearly independent from the specific physical context and it appears to be consistent with the typical behavior of global geometric properties of standard torus knots. Computations of various quantities, such as first-order elastic energy (bending and torsional) of thin rods22 and kinetic energy of vortex filaments23 (see inset of Fig. 4) demonstrate a remarkable similarity with the monotonically decreasing sequence of HOMFLYPT values.
Concluding Remarks
The results presented here hold true for any sub-sequence of standardly embedded torus knots and links in the family {T(2, n)}± under the assumption that any topological transition between contiguous knot/link types in {T(2, n)}± is produced by a single, anti-parallel reconnection event. Standard embedding implies maximal symmetry and minimal crossing presentation, that is, in a way, reminiscent of the ideal shape concept. Such a requirement mimics the initial conditions chosen for the cascade process11,12,13 and it is essential in the mathematical proof given above. A very different scenario can indeed be envisaged for an initial configuration far from “ideal”. Take for example the standardly embedded knot T(2, 5) shown in Fig. 5a. Consider the encircled region and its representation given by the central diagram (top row). Suppose to deform one of the strands continuously around the other (as indicated by the dashed arrows) so that two neighboring parts of the coiled strand reconnect to produce a single loop. The resulting system, shown in Fig. 5b, is the connected sum of a trefoil knot and a Hopf link denoted by 3_1#2_2_1 (topologically different from the connected sum of the standardly embedded T(2, 3)#T(2, 2)). This composite knot has same topological complexity (cmin = n = 5) of the original T(2, 5), but very different geometry and topology.
The same argument applied to the torus link T(2, 6) gives the composite knot 3_1#3_1 (connected sum of two trefoil knots), again with same topological complexity of T(2, 6) but very different geometry and topology. By using a basic property of the HOMFLYPT polynomial24 for composite knots (say K1 and K2), given by
we can compute HOMFLYPT for the two cases above and compare these values with the values obtained for the sequence of standardly embedded knot types. We find
that shows that an alternative path of monotonically decreasing values (given by the bottom branch above) is possible if we drop the assumption (A1) of standard embedding. The same can happen for other knot types of higher topological complexity. Work to establish probability paths associated with alternative topological cascade scenarios is currently under way (Mariel Vasquez, private communication) and no doubt these results will help to choose more appropriate values for the probability factors λω and λτ.
What HOMFLYPT computational values may say in terms of physics is not yet clear. However, as shown by the inset of Fig. 4, there is an unambiguous correspondence between HOMFLYPT computations and various properties of physical knots. As discussed in earlier work15 the present results demonstrate that HOMFLYPT values — rooted in writhe and twist helicity contributions — provide new information to identify and quantify the topology of complex systems. If standard knot polynomials can help to classify different topologies, our adapted HOMFLYPT polynomial can measure these topological differences by attaching a number to any stage of the evolution. How these numbers can be related to energy (or some other fundamental physical property of the system) is not yet clear, but there is no question that further application of this technique to experimental or observational data will help to uncover and possibly establish new relationships between behavior of physical systems, energy and structural complexity. We believe this will open the door to a myriad of possible applications, from energy estimates in braided magnetic fields in solar flares to energy transfers in turbulent flows, from entropy measures in disordered systems to functional prescriptions of recombinant DNA plasmids.
Additional Information
How to cite this article: Liu, X. and Ricca, R. L. Knots cascade detected by a monotonically decreasing sequence of values. Sci. Rep. 6, 24118; doi: 10.1038/srep24118 (2016).
References
Kida, S. & Takaoka, M. Vortex reconnection. Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 26, 169–189 (1994).
Bewley, G., Paoletti, M. S., Sreenivasan, K. R. & Lathrop, D. P. Characterization of reconnecting vortices in superfluid helium. PNAS USA 105, 13707–13710 (2008).
Priest, E. & Forbes, T. Magnetic Reconnection (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2000).
Lugomer, S. Vortex ring reconnection in laser-matter interactions. J. Fluids & Structures 13, 647–661 (1999).
Sumners, De W. Lifting the curtain: using topology to probe the hidden action of enzymes. Notices AMS 42, 528–537 (1995).
Vologodskii, A. V. et al. Sedimentation and electrophoretic migration of DNA knots and catenates. J. Mol. Biol. 278, 1–3 (1998).
van Rees, W., Hussain, F. & Koumoutsakos, P. Vortex tube reconnection at Re = 104. Phys. Fluids 24, 075105-1–14 (2012).
Zuccher, S., Caliari, M., Baggaley, A. W. & Barenghi, C. F. Quantum vortex reconnection. Phys. Fluids 24, 1251081–21 (2012).
Pontin, D. I. Three-dimensional magnetic reconnection regimes: A review. Adv. Space Research 47, 1508–1522 (2011).
Crisona, N. J., Weinberg, R. L., Peter, B. J., Sumners, De W. & Cozzarelli, N. R. The topological mechanism of phage lambda integrase. J. Mol. Biology 289, 747–775 (1999).
Kleckner, D. & Irvine, W. T. M. Creation and dynamics of knotted vortices. Nature Physics 9, 253–258 (2013).
Kleckner, D., Kauffman, L. H. & Irvine, W. T. M. How superfuid vortex knots untie, arXiv:1507.07579v1 [physics.flu-dyn], 27 Jul (2015).
Shimokawa, K., Ishihara, K., Grainge, I., Sherratt, D. J. & Vazquez, M. FtsK-dependent XerCD-dif recombination unlinks replication catenanes in a stepwise manner. PNAS USA 110, 20906–20911 (2013).
Liu, X. & Ricca, R. L. The Jones polynomial for fluid knots from helicity. J. Phys. A: Math. & Theor. 45, 205501 (2012).
Liu, X. & Ricca, R. L. On the derivation of the HOMFLYPT polynomial invariant for fluid knots. J. Fluid Mech. 773, 34–48 (2015).
Kauffman, L. H. Knots and Physics (World Scientific, Singapore, 2001).
Morrison, S. & Bar-Natan, D. KnotAtlas, http://katlas.org/wiki/Main_Page Date of access: 18/02/2016 (2015).
Ricca, R. L. & Liu, X. The Jones polynomial as a new invariant of topological fluid dynamics. Fluid Dyn. Res. 46, 061412 (2014).
Fuller, B. The writhing number of a space curve. PNAS USA 68, 815–819 (1971).
Moffatt, H. K. & Ricca, R. L. Helicity and the Călugăreanu invariant. Proc. Roy. Soc. London A 439, 411–429 (1992).
Laing, C. E., Ricca, R. L. & Sumners, D. W. L. Conservation of writhe helicity under anti-parallel reconnection. Sci. Rep. 5, 9224 (2015).
Oberti, C. Induction effects of torus knots and unknots, PhD Thesis, University of Milano-Bicocca https://boa.unimib.it/retrieve/handle/10281/87792/129043/phd-unimib-067151.pdf, Date of access: 18/02/2016 (2015).
Maggioni, F., Alamri, S. Z., Barenghi, C. F. & Ricca, R. L. Velocity, energy, and helicity of vortex knots and unknots. Phys. Rev. E 82, 26309–26317 (2010).
Lickorish, W. B. R. & Millett, K. C. The new polynomial invariants of knots and links. Mathematics Mag. 61, 3–23 (1988).
Proment, D., Onorato, M. & Barenghi, C. F. Vortex knots in a Bose-Einstein condensate. Phys. Rev. E 85, 036306 (2012).
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to De Witt Sumners, who addressed our attention to the papers in refs 12 and 13, and prompted us to prove the results presented here. We would also like to thank Mariel Vasquez for sharing some information on work in preparation and an anonymous referee for very useful comments. X.L. and R.L.R. acknowledge financial support from the Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC, N. 11572005) and X.L. is indebted to the Haiju Project Fellowship (Beijing).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
The main results are based on preliminary ideas put forward by R.L.R. Actual computations were done by X.L. The paper was written by R.L.R. Revisions following the suggestions of referees were done by R.L.R.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Liu, X., Ricca, R. Knots cascade detected by a monotonically decreasing sequence of values. Sci Rep 6, 24118 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep24118
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/srep24118
This article is cited by
-
Minimal unlinking pathways as geodesics in knot polynomial space
Communications Physics (2020)
-
Knot spectrum of turbulence
Scientific Reports (2019)
-
Influence of winding number on vortex knots dynamics
Scientific Reports (2019)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.